I Can't Tell If This Is A Joke....

...Or he really thinks that's how the game works: You’re Not My Real Big Daddy

“Don’t shoot me!” said the Little Sister. But was she lying?

Can a request be a lie, really? The only example I've thought of is this:

Please don't hit me with your penis, madam.

...and even then it's circumstantial.

Oh, and if you haven't played Bioshock yet, you should. Seriously, do it. I'm tired of sitting on these spoilers.